How to Support Your Teen When You’re Not a Fan of Their Friend 

As a therapist who specializes in working with teens, one thing I hear from parents time and time again is how difficult it can be to navigate their teen’s friendships. I get a lot of exacerbated and frustrated parents asking for advice on how to help their kid form healthier friendships. 

“Murphy, I don’t know why they are so invested in this friendship, it's so toxic. I wish I could just get them to see it.” 

Or
“I just tell keep telling them, when you’re older you’ll realize how unimportant this really was.”

You mean well, but naturally your teen disregards your suggestion, or worse shuts down or pulls away. You’re stuck in this difficult position, and so is your teen. They’re at a stage in life where they’re learning to become more independent while still needing the support and guidance of others. In other words, they need room to figure things out on their own, but they also need to know you’re there when they need you. 

Why Teen Friendships Can Feel So High-Stakes

You’ve probably heard this before, as humans we are incredibly social creatures. It’s true, we need others not just to survive, but to thrive. Supportive friendships are associated with fewer mental health difficulties, with social inclusion being found as a major factor in protecting against depression and anxiety (Hunt et al., 2023). For teens, this is especially important as they begin to develop a sense of independence, navigate the world beyond their family, and figure out who they are outside of the familiar relationships and routines of home. 

During adolescence, friendships often become a bigger part of how teens understand themselves and where they fit in the world. Feeling accepted by peers can mean a lot, and the possibility of being left out or misunderstood can feel especially painful. Not only do you get companionship, but there’s survival in numbers. “By being a part of an adolescent group, you get companionship on this transitional trek, as well as safety in numbers: Predators will be intimidated by a large group, and you can lose yourself in the group mass. That is one reason why for many but not all teens, fitting in can feel so important - it’s an evolutionary holdover for life or death.” (Siegel, 2015).

At the same time, teens are still learning how to navigate these relationships while developing self-awareness, communicating their needs and feelings, working through disagreements, and figuring out who they are. When friendships get complicated, it can be hard for them to know how to respond or what to do next.

As a parent, it can be tempting to tell your teen to move on from a friendship that seems to be causing more stress than happiness. But telling them to stop looking for a best friend or a close-knit group can leave them feeling misunderstood. The need for connection and belonging is real, and dismissing it may make your teen less likely to turn to you when they're struggling. Instead, how you approach these conversations can make a difference in whether your teen feels comfortable coming to you for support or starts keeping their friendship struggles to themselves.

Why Telling Your Teen to Drop a Friend Can Backfire

1. It Can Dismiss a Normal Part of Growing Up

During adolescence, friendships often become an important source of belonging, support, and identity. Teens are learning how to build close relationships and figure out who they are outside of their family. When you dismiss the importance of a friendship, even one that seems messy from the outside, your teen may feel like you're dismissing something of them and who they are.

2. It Can Make the Fear of Being Alone Feel Even Bigger

Even when a friendship is stressful, the thought of walking away can feel overwhelming. Your teen might worry about being left out, losing their social circle, or not finding another close friend. Being alone is scary, especially when you haven’t quite figured out who you are. Simply telling them to end the friendship doesn't address those fears. They probably just need help navigating the uncertainty and figuring out what they want from their relationships.

3. It Can Make Your Teen Less Likely to Open Up

When teens expect their parents to criticize a friend or tell them what to do, they may start keeping friendship struggles to themselves. They might worry that sharing what's happening will lead to judgment, conflict, or pressure to end the relationship. Creating space for honest conversations helps teens feel more comfortable coming to you when things get difficult.

4. It Can Backlash and Push Them Closer to the Friend

When a teen feels like their parent doesn't understand or accept an important friendship, it can cause them to become more protective of that relationship. Instead of reflecting on what's working and what isn't, they may feel the need to defend their friend or hold on more tightly. Approaching the situation with curiosity rather than criticism can help your teen feel less defensive and more open to considering different perspectives.

How to Talk To Your Teen About Their Friends

1. Don’t Talk Down To Them

The best way to do this is to find some time to spend with your teen doing something together. This quality time will allow you time and space to get curious about their world. Ask them about their friends, what they like about them, what they enjoy doing together, segue into topics like can you have a different opinion, how do you share with them if you’re having conflict. 

2. Stop Talking and Start Listening

I say this to parents all the time, stop judging and get curious. If you’re interjecting too much it takes their ability to think away for themselves. They need your help in determining if their relationship is healthy, but not by you telling them that (they probably wouldn't listen if you told them anyways). Use some active listening skills, like “it sounds like you were uncomfortable with that” or “you wanted them to know you needed some space to yourself.” This conversation is much more empowering for you child because it feels less like you trying to tell them what to think or do, and more about you seeing their progress and ability to make healthy decisions. 

3. Don’t Point The Finger At Their Friend

It can be tempting to blame your child's friend or jump in and fix the situation. You’re protective of your child, or annoyed that this is the five hundredth time you’ve heard this story (both incredibly valid). 

But friendships can be complicated. Sometimes its building awareness this isn’t a healthy relationship. But other times its realizing there was a misunderstanding, you had different values or expectations, things weren’t communicated, or you just changed what you needed from the friendship. Conflict is an inevitable part of life, and relationships. You’re teen needs to be able to navigate how to handle conflicts without breaking things off

Rather than immediately labeling a friend as toxic or deciding who is at fault, try getting curious about your teen's experience. What happened? How did it make them feel? What do they want to happen next? What feels difficult about addressing it with their friend?

When teens feel heard rather than judged, they're more likely to open up. You can help them recognize unhealthy patterns, consider different perspectives, and decide what they need from their relationships while still trusting their own judgment.

4. Stop Contradicting Them or Telling Them “I Told You So”

This is a tough one. Sometimes you’re teen is just gonna get it wrong. As adults that can be hard, you don’t want to see them struggle. But it’s important to give them the space to fail, without it they’ll never learn to what success looks like. 

Listen without challenging their perspective. If you ask what happened and your teen shares their experience, try to resist the urge to contradict their interpretation or explain why their friend might have acted differently. Even when you see the situation another way, leading with disagreement can make your teen feel misunderstood or less willing to open up in the future.

If you have strong feelings about the friend or want to share an observation that might come across as critical, consider writing it down first rather than saying it in the moment. This gives you space to process your own reactions without putting your teen in a position where they feel they need to defend their friend (or themselves).

You don't have to agree with every conclusion your teen draws to validate their feelings. Sometimes, the most helpful thing you can do is listen, stay curious, and give them room to make sense of the experience in their own way.

Support for Teens Navigating Friendship Challenges

We can love our teens deeply and still struggle with some of their choices, including the friends they choose. When we disagree with those choices, it can be hard to balance our concerns with making sure our teens still feel safe coming to us. We can’t choose our teen’s friends for them, but we can choose how we respond when we’re worried. Approaching these conversations with curiosity, compassion, and open communication helps keep the door open, so our teens know they can turn to us for support, even when we don’t see things the same way. 

Citations

Hunt, X., Shakespeare, T., Vilyte, G., Melendez-Torres, G. J., Henry, J., Bradshaw, M., Naidoo, S., Mbuyamba, R., Aljassem, S., Suubi, E., Aljasem, N., Makhetha, M., & Bantjes, J. (2023). Effectiveness of Social Inclusion Interventions for Anxiety and Depression among Adolescents: A Systematic Review. International journal of environmental research and public health, 20(3), 1895. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031895

Siegel, D. J. (2015). Brainstorm: The power and purpose of the teenage brain. TarcherPerigee. (Note: Depending on the specific edition or print run, publisher details may also be listed as Penguin Putnam or Jeremy P. Tarcher/Penguin).


Next
Next

Healing Beyond Strength: A Holistic Approach to Men’s Mental Health